Can My HOA Really Fine Me? Legal Limits on HOA Enforcement

Homeowners Associations (HOAs) play a major role in maintaining community standards, but many homeowners are surprised to learn just how much authority their HOA has—including the ability to impose fines. But can your HOA really fine you? The answer is yes—but only within legal limits. Understanding these boundaries is crucial to protecting your rights as a homeowner.

The Basics of HOA Authority

When you buy a home in an HOA-governed community, you agree to follow its rules—typically laid out in the Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs), as well as bylaws and community guidelines. These documents outline what the HOA can regulate, from paint colors and landscaping to parking and pet policies.

In most states, including California, HOAs have the legal authority to issue fines for rule violations. However, that power isn’t unlimited.

Discover: Can an HOA Enter Your Property to Fix Landscaping Without Permission?

Legal Requirements for Fining Homeowners

Here are several important legal limits and procedural requirements your HOA must follow to fine you:

1. Due Process

Before imposing a fine, the HOA must provide notice and an opportunity for a hearing. For example, California’s Civil Code §5855 requires that the HOA notify the homeowner in writing at least 10 days before the hearing, stating the nature of the violation and the date of the hearing.

2. Consistent Rule Enforcement

HOAs must apply rules consistently and uniformly. If they selectively enforce violations or single out certain homeowners, they may be in violation of state laws and open to legal challenges.

3. Fines Must Be Reasonable

The amount of the fine must be reasonable and clearly stated in the association's governing documents. Excessive or arbitrary fines—such as hundreds of dollars for minor infractions—can be contested legally.

4. Notice of Decision

After a hearing, the HOA must notify the homeowner of its decision and the amount of any fine imposed—typically within 15 days in writing.

5. Limits on Enforcement Methods

While HOAs can impose fines and even place liens for unpaid dues or certain violations, there are limits. For example, in California, an HOA cannot foreclose on a home for unpaid fines alone unless the debt exceeds $1,800 or is at least 12 months delinquent, and proper legal steps are taken.

What You Can Do If You’re Fined

If you receive a fine:

• Request a copy of the rule you allegedly violated.
• Ask for documentation showing how the HOA determined the violation.
• Attend the hearing and present your case.
• Appeal the decision if allowed in your governing documents.

If you believe your HOA acted unfairly or illegally, you may file a complaint with your state’s Department of Consumer Affairs or consult with a real estate attorney.

Conclusion

Yes, your HOA can fine you—but it must follow the law, provide due process, and apply rules consistently. As a homeowner, you have the right to challenge unjust fines and demand transparency. Knowing your rights and staying informed about your community’s rules can help you navigate HOA enforcement with confidence.

For legal help in California and your other needs, contact BERYS LAW on this page. We also offer courses on real estate investing, landlording, and templates right here!