How Employers Should Document Performance Issues

Performance management is a critical part of running any successful organization. When employees are not meeting expectations, it’s the employer’s responsibility to address the issue promptly and professionally. However, many businesses fail to properly document performance concerns, which can lead to legal vulnerabilities, decreased morale, and inconsistent team standards. Effective documentation not only supports fair treatment but also helps foster accountability and growth.

Why Documentation Matters

Proper documentation serves several purposes. First, it creates a clear record of expectations and behavior patterns over time, ensuring objectivity in performance evaluations. Second, it protects the company in the event of legal disputes. If an employee claims wrongful termination or discrimination, detailed documentation provides evidence that decisions were based on legitimate, job-related reasons. Finally, it provides a roadmap for employees to improve by clarifying issues and setting specific expectations.

What Should Be Documented?

• Specific Behaviors or Incidents: Avoid vague statements like “John has a bad attitude.” Instead, write: “On July 1, John raised his voice at a coworker during a team meeting, stating, ‘This is a waste of time,’ which disrupted the discussion and impacted team morale.”
• Dates and Times: Always include when the performance issue occurred. This helps establish patterns and timelines, especially if disciplinary action or termination becomes necessary later.
• Expectations vs. Behavior: Clearly identify the standard or expectation the employee failed to meet. For example: “Employee was expected to submit weekly reports by Friday 5 PM. Over the past month, three reports were turned in late without prior notice.”
• Employee Response: Document how the employee reacted to feedback or corrective actions. This provides insight into their willingness to improve and helps demonstrate fair treatment.
• Action Taken: Note any steps the company took, such as verbal warnings, coaching sessions, or performance improvement plans (PIPs). This shows that the employer made a good-faith effort to support the employee.
• Future Expectations and Timeline: End every document with a clear outline of what improvement is expected and by when. For example: “Employee must reduce customer complaint rate by 50% over the next 30 days.”

Best Practices for Documentation

Keep It Objective: Focus on facts and observable behavior, not opinions or assumptions.

Use a Consistent Format: Whether you use performance logs, emails, or formal HR forms, make sure documentation is consistent across departments.

Review with the Employee: Allow the employee to review and sign the documentation. Even if they disagree, their signature confirms they received the information.

Store Securely: Maintain documentation in a secure, confidential HR file separate from general personnel records.

Final Thoughts

Performance issues are inevitable, but how employers handle them makes all the difference. Documentation isn't about creating a “paper trail” to punish employees—it’s about promoting clarity, fairness, and growth. When done correctly, it empowers both the employer and the employee to address challenges constructively and move forward with confidence.

For legal help in California and your other needs, contact BERYS LAW on this page. We also offer courses on real estate investing, landlording, and templates right here!