Seller Refusing to Close Escrow? Your Legal Rights and Remedies

The process of buying a home can be exciting yet complex. One crucial part of a real estate transaction is closing escrow, which ensures the transfer of funds, documents, and property ownership between the buyer and seller. But what happens when the seller refuses to close escrow? This can be frustrating for the buyer, as it may lead to delays, additional costs, or even the loss of the desired property. If you're in this situation, it's important to know your legal rights and remedies to protect your interests.

Understanding Escrow

Escrow is a neutral third-party service that holds funds, property deeds, and other important documents until all conditions of the real estate contract are fulfilled. This ensures that the buyer and seller both meet their obligations before the transaction is completed. Once all conditions have been met, escrow is "closed," and the property title is transferred to the buyer.

Common Reasons Sellers Refuse to Close Escrow

Sellers may refuse to close escrow for several reasons, including:

Seller's Remorse: The seller may have second thoughts about selling the property, either because they believe they can get a better price elsewhere or because they are emotionally attached to the home.

Financing Issues: If the seller is purchasing another property and their financing falls through, they may delay or refuse to close escrow to avoid being left without a home.

Disputes Over Repairs: The seller may be unwilling to complete agreed-upon repairs or address issues discovered during the inspection, leading to a breakdown in the transaction.

Higher Offer Received: The seller might receive a higher offer from another buyer and refuse to close in hopes of canceling the original contract.

Legal Rights of the Buyer

If a seller refuses to close escrow without a valid reason, the buyer has legal rights to enforce the contract. Real estate purchase agreements are legally binding, and both parties must fulfill their contractual obligations unless they have a lawful excuse not to. Here are some of the legal rights buyers may have:

Specific Performance: In many states, real estate is considered unique, which allows the buyer to sue for "specific performance." This means the court can compel the seller to complete the sale as agreed in the contract. This remedy is particularly useful if the buyer still wants the property, as it forces the seller to honor the agreement.

Damages: If the buyer no longer wishes to purchase the property or specific performance is not an option, the buyer may sue the seller for monetary damages. This could include compensation for additional costs, such as temporary housing or storage, and any increase in interest rates if the buyer’s loan terms have changed due to the delay.

Cancel the Contract and Get a Refund: In some cases, the buyer may simply choose to cancel the contract and walk away from the transaction. If the seller is at fault, the buyer is usually entitled to a refund of their deposit and any other funds held in escrow. Additionally, the buyer may also be able to recover other costs incurred during the transaction, such as appraisal or inspection fees.

Remedies to Resolve the Issue

If a seller refuses to close escrow, there are several steps a buyer can take before pursuing legal action:

Negotiation: Often, issues can be resolved through open communication. The buyer and seller may be able to renegotiate terms, such as extending the closing date or offering a concession for the delay.

Mediation or Arbitration: Some real estate contracts require disputes to be resolved through mediation or arbitration. These are less formal and often less expensive alternatives to court litigation. If the contract includes an arbitration clause, this process must be followed before going to court.

Legal Action: If negotiation or mediation fails, the buyer can pursue legal action, such as filing a lawsuit for specific performance or damages.

Conclusion

A seller's refusal to close escrow can be stressful and may jeopardize the entire real estate transaction. However, buyers have legal rights and remedies available to protect their interests. Whether through negotiation, mediation, or legal action, it’s important to act quickly and consult with a real estate attorney to ensure the best possible outcome. With the right approach, buyers can either secure the property or recover any losses caused by the seller's refusal.

Discover more real estate articles here:

• What Is Foreclosure? And Your Legal Rights
• How to Resolve Retaining Wall Disputes
• What Are Easement Disputes?
• What Is HELOC Fraud and How Can Homeowners Protect Themselves?

For legal help in California and your other needs, contact BERYS LAW on this page. We also offer courses on real estate investing, landlording, and templates right here!